Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix - Dictator/General/Conqueror
The poor guy had a terrible case of rosacea, according to some ancient sources, but they all agree that he was quite the scary/attractive guy with piercing blue eyes and blonde hair.
Aside from generally good looking busts, this guy also marched on Rome not once but twice [in between ending drawn-out wars quickly and taking out Mithridates in Asia Minor] and became its dictator after the second time. Surprisingly, he retired from dictatorship and lived quietly in the country with his lover afterwards. He had also held consulship twice.